Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'General Questions' started by Bd182, Feb 11, 2019.
I print at 60mm/sec. Makerbot runs at 150mm/sec. What happens if I set the R1+ to that speed?
You will likely have a mess on your hands. Because of the printer style of the R1 (based on the Mendel 90) you won't get speeds much over 60 mm/s with satisfactory results.
I can promise you makerbot does not run those speeds in reality. Had a 5th gen I was fixing where that was the claim, but at 40mm/s my Robo out ran it on the same print files. Remember, jerk, accel, speed overrides from slicer etc all slow down whatever you set your speeds to.
I typically suggest as @WheresWaldo did. Not more than 60mm/s. You wont notice much of a time difference at 50mm/s.
At one time I ran all my R1s around 80mm/s but it wasn't pretty doing the repairs all the time and listening to the horrid noises just wasn't worth it
Yeah, I looked up the MakerBot 2 online and it doesn't claim 150mm/sec. I loaded MatterControl with a driver for the MakerBot and it's speeds were similar to the R1. I think my friend must have been looking at his maximum travel speed, not printing speeds.
But, Ultimaker claims 200mm/sec. Do they really such higher print speeds by offloading the weight of the filament feeder to the frame?
There are a number of ways to get better acceleration and speed without sacrificing stability in a mechanical design such as the printer.
Less moving parts and/or less moving mass are both valid approaches. A tighter more rigid framework is another (and one reason gantry style printers -- like the R2-- generally are more stable. In the end it is a trade-off like almost everything else in the world
I've had my R1 for a month, so I'm green. The feature I most want is more speed. These things are s-l-o-w!
You can by converting to a pure Bowden setup increase the speed and acceleration some (since all of the extruder weight is pushed off somewhere else). But... that is a fair amount of work for what amounts to a less than impressive speed increase It matters, but it will not double your print speed (you might achieve a 30%-50% increase if you do it right). There are some projects on here where folks did that if you want to research it.
Really the only way to get a significantly faster printer is to get a different style.
I'm perfectly happy with my R1 for now. But one dreams of another machine down the road. Can an Ultimaker really print at 200mm/sec?
Is an R2 the "different style"? I looked up specs, but it rates speed by volume rather than distance. The spec on my R1 is given as distance, so I can't compare them.
The R2 is A different style (gantry opposed to RepRap/Mendel 90 like the R1)
If you look at how the belts/axis are setup and movement is done you can see that it is a totally different approach to movement (example -- the bed moves up and down -- not back and forth so there is less opportunity for drive lash in that axis and the gantry itself helps to minimize lash as well). The Z (up and down) is always less violent moves than X or Y
There are many different styles of FDM printers (deltas/polar coordinate printers are yet another) and quite a few styles of SLA/DLP ones too. With a DLP printer Z is the only motion (and that is still slow) .
I have quite a few printers - they are all slow . Even my Ultimaker. If you have no need for quality put a volcano hotend on it and print huge layers to get fast prints- they will be uglier- but fast. Its all about how you want your set up to be
I have a volcano on one of 0the R1s and print 1.0mm or 1.2mm nozzles ALL THE TIME
Fast? Heh, smoking fast compared to the 0.4 nozzle. After all -- 3 times as much plastic is getting put down at once.
And you really don't sacrifice much on larger models (and small ones are faster so why use a volcano?)
I finally broke down and have one R1 series running the volcano with a 1.0 nozzle and it makes all my jigs and fixtures. Nice and fast ugly if I leave the layer height high (anything over .5 layers and its real ugly) but fast Full build volume (about half height) is around 5-8 hours give or take. Nice to have one set up that way for sure.
Something large I don't care about 1mm lines and heck -- half the time will be sanded, primed, painted anyway.